Blasting Stereotypes in Autistic Females
It's no secret that more males than females are diagnosed as being on the autism spectrum. Evidence shows that there are differing behaviors between autistic males and females. Some feel the diagnostic criteria for Autism Spectrum Disorders, the DSM IV has neglected to address this important issue. The theory of autism being a form of an "extreme male brain" may be at work as well—and not always to the advantage of us unique and varied autistic ladies!
When people question if autism is really different in females than it is in males, I find myself thrown back into a nice neat square box from which it seems there is no escape. Though he’s behind the “extreme male brain” theory, Dr. Simon Baron Cohen has stated that we shouldn't assume that autism would look the same in both sexes. This is no moot point, as there are a lot of females who are either passed over, or denied a diagnosis, due to the lack of sensitivity in regards to ferreting out the distinctive differences related to how autism may present from individual to individual.
Dr. Judith Gould from the National Autistic Society states that characteristics such as shyness and over-sensitivity, common in autistic people, are sometimes deemed to be typically female traits.
David Skuse, a psychiatry professor from Institute of Child Health at University College London adds that because girls' general aptitude for communication and their social competence helps some females on the autistic spectrum "pass"—they pick up on their difference and carefully mask it by mimicking other girls' speech, manner, and dress.
As an autistic female, I can identify and attest to Dr. Skuse's commentary, as it is true in my case. When I disclose my diagnosis as an autistic person, it is not uncommon for me to hear these types of remarks:
"You seem so with it! Matter of fact, I have always admired how together you seem to be."
Meanwhile, I am thinking about how shattered someone's image of me would be if only they knew how cantankerous and unreliable my executive functioning skills are. I conjure images of people visiting me at my home and becoming alarmed at my sudden change in behavior if too many things are set out of place. (Also mentionable, is my incessant staring off into space, trying to remember what it is that I was, or am supposed to be, doing.)
"But you speak so well and seem to have so much going for you! You’re so articulate. Gosh, I would never have known!"
When I hear these types of comments, which are often well-intentioned, it is reiterated that autism myths—including what autistic people should look and act like—need to be stamped out for good. It is especially important to realize that autistic people possess uneven skills. For example, being articulate, wearing make-up, and dressing in clothes that I think are fashionable, does NOT mean that I have it together.
Haven't we all been warned not to judge books by their covers? Simply put, casually pointing fingers—or not—at autism is a subjective business.
Here are some suggested links for further exploration on this topic (mini-disclaimer: there are a few insensitive references about autism in a some of the links below):
- BBC News: Autism ‘may be missed in girls’
- The New York Times: What Autistic Girls Are Made Of
- The Telegraph: Autistic women: a life more ordinary
- Street Roots: Pretending to be normal: A photo story of Asperger’s syndrome
About the author, Elesia Ashkenazy.
Posted in:
- Autistic People
- autism
- autism women's network
- autistic females
- AWN
- BBC News: Autism ‘may be missed in girls’
- blasting stereotypes
- David Skuse
- Dr. Judith Gould
- DSM IV
- extreme male brain
- Institute of Child Health at University College London
- National Autistic Society
- New York Times: What Autistic Girls Are Made Of
- Simon Baron Cohen
- Street Roots: Pretending to be normal: A photo story of Asperger’s syndrome
- The Telegraph: Autistic women: a life more ordinary



Comments
When I was seeking a diagnosis I had a psychologist tell me flat-out that I could not possibly have an autism spectrum disorder because girls aren't autistic.
I guess I was fortunate in that I didn't fall into the female sterotype - as much as I am feminine and not a 'tom-boy', I never learned how to get along with females...least of all mimic them, and I'm far from "shy" (even if people do call me "shy" to explain or excuse to my silence in new situations). I got my autism diagnosis straight away, although I admit to being surprised that it wasn't Asperger's insteadlike I had suspected for years, I'll also admit to holding some sterotypes towards autistic people which made being told I was 'autistic' rather than 'aspie' a little tricky to get my head around at first.
Me too. I feel that I'm mostly OK with "pretending to be normal" but it doesn't coming naturally. If Aspy boys got as much social skills indoctrination as Aspy girls do from early childhood, some of them may grow up with better pretending skills too.
My belief is that you can never base a diagnosis of autism solely on outward behaviors, since autism is how your brain functions and it is internal. Neither should you base it on gender expectaitions. The male brain thing kind of makes me angry.
Just started reaindg Thinking in Pictures and am looking forward to watching the movie on HBO. Ms. Grandin's emphasis on the need to use the strengths and interests of students is the essential ingredient in engaging students.
Amazing. I just read the NYTimes article and I definitely agree with that article; society's perception of how a person should act will definitely impact anyone and could potentially be unable to detect anyone who is, in fact, autistic. I definitely think environment plays a role, and, depending on the culture, and where the autistic person falls on the spectrum, the individual in question could go undetected.
In some cultures, being talkative is, in fact, highly discouraged, and there are settings that are highly structured, for ex. where classes are the same every week, if not every day and students are assigned in groups periodically. Depending on where the individual stands on the spectrum, this may be an effective environment for someone who is autistic.
However, in a culture that highly values interaction at any level and between any individual, and if the classroom setting is less structured, I think the characteristics can be exacerbated and made more obvious, to the autistic person, maybe, if not the immediate surroundings.
Because of this, there has to be more to autism than a lot of the surface traits, which could even be indicative of a completely different disorder, culture, or personality type. I suspect it may have a lot to do with how the individual adapts to changes in his or her environment over time, socially or otherwise.
Well, I grew up "shy" and "over sensitive", was an absolute math whiz (my salvation), and guess what? It sure has been darn hard to find a spouse, but I found him. It sure has been darn hard to keep the average Joe from incessantly trespassing my heretofore very weak boundaries, and having social groups exclude me and/or gang up on me - even my own family, especially my own family. It sure has been hard to fit in, to feel like I would not become the office butt. I observed the old adage that a rolling stone gathers no moss, but most employers want a person who is going to dig in and stay a long time. I just did not have that ability. I got run off way too easily, and/or was so traumatized that I left first, out of paranoia, before I could be further bullied. Much, much difficulty with psychic boundaries and not taking on other's people stuff, who should never have dumped it, or tried to, on me to begin with. The more dysfunctional the group/people, the more stuff they tried to dump on me. But I do have a little bit to show for all the years of hard work, just not a lot. And the boundaries are getting a little firmer/flexible and still intact, even at age 56. It sure has been hard learning to accept myself and trying to understand why I have always been so different. Sometimes those differences were an asset, but mostly not. I'm tired. Never a diagnosis - gave up on the idiot psych profession a long time ago - until I started reading some Pre and Perinatal Psychology, something our culture has little to no clue about. I also got a thorough education on emotions and how to access those I was not aware of throughout the years. I also got an education on how my screwed up family had an abysmally low EQ, in spite of high IQs, and how so many people try to project their uncomfortable feelings onto me, just because I am different, and had sort of a psychic void at times. I feel there is a whole lot more to just a diagnosis than meets the eye. Thanks for this info....
Post new comment